Could your phone be next bomb? Scary truth about remote explosions
Mumbai to Pune in 2 hrs with new expressway, Atal Setu to play crucial link
Haryana Assembly Elections 2024: AAP chief Arvind Kejriwal to kick-start poll campaign today
Bangladesh pacer Hasan Mahmud joins Dale Steyn to record rare feat in IND vs BAN 1st Test
Meet woman, who scored 97% in class 12, secured 705 out of 720 marks in NEET exam, her AIR is...
PM Modi to visit Maharashtra today, to unveil major initiatives for...
iPhone 16 series sale starts today: Check price in India, bank offers, cashbacks, offers and more
This Indian palace has been underwater for 221 years, remains undamaged, it is located in...
DNA TV Show: Row over fat-containing laddus in Tirupati Temple
Kolkata rape-murder case: Junior doctors to end protest, resume emergency services from...
Salman Khan's security breached, case registered against biker following actor's car
Sarfaraz Ahmed trolls Babar Azam in Champions One-Day Cup, star batter responds with century
After reducing debt, Anil Ambani's company now approves Rs 3014 crore...
Legends League Cricket 2024: Full schedule, squads, live streaming - All you need to know
India reacts to report on diversion of Indian defence exports to Ukraine, says, ‘it is…’
Tata Group-owned app to deliver iPhone 16 models in 10 minutes, service starts from…
Amitabh Bachchan apologises for this reason in viral video: 'Galat ho gaya tha...'
New COVID-19’s XEC 'contagious' variant spreads across 27 countries, here's what you need to know
Verantes Living Awarded as India’s No.1 Stainless Steel Modular Kitchen Brand
Narayana Murthy’s Infosys set to invest Rs 170000000 in this startup
Discover Stainless France, the Leading Supplier of Cobalt Chrome
India dismisses Khalistani terrorist Pannun's US lawsuit over assassination attempt, calls it…
IND vs BAN, 1st Test: R Ashwin joins Ravindra Jadeja in elite club, becomes second cricketer to....
More trouble for ex-RG Kar principal Sandip Ghosh, Bengal medical body now...
Tirupati Laddu row: Lab report confirms prasada contains beef fat, fish oil
Meet IPS officer who has resigned after serving for 18 yrs due to...
ITR filing: Haven’t received your income tax refund yet? Here’s what you should do
FATF says India faces severe 'terrorist financing threats' from...
WATCH: IAS officer poses as customer at liquor shop, imposes Rs 50000 fine for....
Meet Indian man, who got hired whopping Rs 12000000 crore salary job, not from IIT, IIM he is...
Meet ‘delivery boy’ who beats Mukesh Ambani in world’s billionaire list, his net worth is…
Suriya, Bobby Deol-starrer Kanguva gets new release date, averts clash with Rajinikanth's Vettaiyan
This Bajaj Group company's shares rose by Rs 1687 in just 5 days after...
5 super expensive assets Mukesh Ambani owns: Rs 15000 crore home, Rs 600 crore jet, MI worth...
IND vs BAN, 1st Test: Shubman Gill joins Virat Kohli in unwanted list after poor outing on Day 1
“I'm gonna cut…”: Know what Andrew Flintoff said to Yuvraj Singh before his 6 sixes feat
Kareena Kapoor revives vintage glam in 25-year-old Banarasi saree makeover
Atishi’s Delhi cabinet: AAP leader to retain four minsters; new face to be included
Centre investigates 26-year-old EY employee's death amid massive outrage
NASA's James Webb unveils black hole starving its host galaxy; see pic
'They will also finish....': Akhilesh Yadav slams BJP over 'one nation, one election'
Housing society issues notice over too many deliveries asks to hire personal watchman
ICC releases venues for women's T20 world cup, check list here
J-K Assembly Election 2024: 'Abdullahs, Muftis, Gandhis have given...,' says PM Modi in Srinagar
Meet woman who left medical career for UPSC exam , became IPS with AIR 165 then left job due to...
Meet Indian billionaire with Rs 32615 crore net worth who wants you to save Rs 600 daily because...
IAS Puja Khedkar case latest update: Delhi HC issues...; Know details here
Haryana Assembly Election 2024: BJP releases election manifesto, guarantees...
Amid Ind vs Ban, why is 'boycottBangladeshCricket' trending on social media? Know here
'Usko dekh...': Rishabh Pant during war of words with Liton Das during Ind vs Ban test
This is world's costliest rice, price of 1 kg will leave you shocked, it is grown in...
Could your phone be the next bomb? The scary truth about remote explosions
Watch video: Rohit Sharma's reaction after Virat Kohli's dismissal in Ind vs Ban test match
Bihar: 15 people held for torching 21 houses in Nawada, government says more arrests likely
Atishi, along with new cabinet, to take oath as Delhi CM on..., know details here
ANALYSIS
Ever since its launch on 14th June 2022, the ambitious “Agnipath Scheme” of India has been a matter of debate and was one of the prominent issues during Indian general elections 2024
TRENDING NOW
Kamlesh (Name changed) belonged to a village in Western Uttar Pradesh. He got recruited as an “Agniveer” in the Indian Army in Mid 2023. Six months later, when he passed out after the training and his parents decided to marry him, they faced a challenge. The parents of the would-be bride refused saying that the boy will be unemployed after four years and hence they cannot marry their daughter with a person having uncertainty about his job. In rural India, where the average education level is very low, such things are not rare.
Ever since its launch on 14th June 2022, the ambitious “Agnipath Scheme” of India has been a matter of debate and was one of the prominent issues during Indian general elections 2024. In India where the common public is still carrying the colonial belief that a government job means pension for the lifetime, such a scheme becoming a controversial issue was inevitable.
There were mistakes on the part of everyone. While the government propagated it as a political achievement, opposition parties criticised it without even knowing the overall need, strategic perspective and its benefits to the soldiers. Media too handled this matter carelessly and as a result, the correct picture did not reach the common public antagonising a large section of the population.
Debunking the Myths
In the light of incidents mentioned above, it is pertinent to understand the reality about this scheme and clear several myths labelled over this scheme.
(a) Myth of degraded operational effectiveness – Many strategists have pointed out that since the Agniveers will have a reduced basic training period, it will compromise the operational effectiveness of the Armed Forces. But the fact is that a soldier is trained throughout his life. After the basic training in the respective regimental centre, an Agniveer is expected to undergo multiple training programs pertaining to his trade and role in war. Moreover, in today’s times, the overall education level of the recruits has improved and hence their trainability becomes better. As a large number of Agniveers have already become part of Armed forces, it is observed that their training standards and their performance is not less than the regular soldiers which proves this point.
(b) Myth of Unemployment of Agniveers – As mentioned earlier, there is a common myth that these Agniveers will be unemployed after their contractual term of four years but recently, nearly all paramilitary forces, several state governments, banks as well as private sector companies announced reservations and other lucrative offers for the Agniveers post their contractual service. In India, the private security industry is growing at an average rate of 10-12% where these people can be easily employed. Not only this, but the financial package offered to any Agniveer post his tenure is also very much lucrative and with the fact that 25% of these Agniveers will be retained in the Armed forces, there should not be any debate on their employment.
(c) Myth of lesser monetary & ex- gratia benefits–Recently after the demise of one of the Agniveers during one operation, there was hue and cry in the media that Agniveers are getting lesser benefits in comparison to other regular soldiers after their death. Both Ministry of Defence and Government clarified it multiple times that there is no difference in the benefits, yet the issue is burning primarily because of lack of education and awareness.
(d) Myth of Criminalising the country – There was a section of people who vehemently argued that the presence of such trained people in our civil society can pose severe danger as some of them may turn criminal. If we see the old scheme where a soldier was expected to serve for fifteen years, the same logic can be applied perfectly. A soldier generally gets recruited at an age of 17-18 and retires at 32-33 after completing 15-year service which cannot be considered old. Despite the fact, the number of retired soldiers turning criminal can be counted on fingers and in all of these cases, family disputes were the reason. So, it is foolish to give such facts to counter the Agnipath scheme.
What should the government do?
In the light of above myths, ideally the government should have done its homework before launching the scheme but somehow, they failed in it. Moreover, the haste under which they launched the scheme has also invited sheer criticism. In such a case, the government should act fast and take some measures which will not only debunk the myths but also help create a favourable atmosphere in favour of “Agnipath scheme”.
(a) Separate cell for re-employment of Agniveers- Although we already have a Directorate General of Resettlement and Ex servicemen placement cells across the three services, the government should seriously think of establishing a separate cell for re-employment of Agniveers. This cell should start working when the Agniveer are in their last year of service and provide them an alternative job which they can take over immediately on their release. Since the first batch of Agniveers is likely to get released in the next two years, the success of their re-employment will help the government run this scheme with ease in future.
(b) Limit the annual intake of Agniveers– One of the points of debate is that the forces are not recruiting regular soldiers and only Agniveer recruitments are being carried out for the last two years. In order to maintain overall operational effectiveness of the Armed Forces and homogeneity, it is essential that the government should fix the annual intake as well as overall percentage of Agniveers in the Defence forces. The ratio between regular soldiers and Agniveers should be healthy and should be as per strategic requirements. In my opinion, the overall percentage of Agniveers should not be more than 25 or 30% in any force. They should also consider the challenges being faced by units having a significant number of Agniveers.
(c) Carry out a thorough study and decide their arms and services- There may be few arms and services where Agniveers can be recruited but there may be few where a high level of technical knowledge is one of the requirements. There are technical arms where a soldier is supposed to train for 3-4 years or more to become operational and hence in such places, recruitment of Agniveers is not recommended. This fact is more applicable in case of the Indian Navy and Indian Air Force.
(d) Educate the common public against the myths – One of the major areas where the government faltered was to educate the common public about this scheme before launching it. Even after two years of its launch, there are a large number of elected representatives of the government who do not know the benefits of this scheme. Media exposure too is very less and under such circumstances, the criticism from the opposition turning into myths and creating hurdles for this scheme. Although the Prime Minister spoke about the scheme during his address at Kargil Vijay Diwas, there is more to do.
I personally feel that the Agnipath Scheme is not bad, it is beneficial for both the Armed Forces as well as the common public from where soldiers are getting recruited. The only drawback was that the government failed to educate people and debunk the myths.
The author is a veteran of the Armed Forces. He is a known Defence Strategist with keen interests in international affairs, maritime security, terrorism and internal security.
(Disclaimer: The views expressed above are the author's own and do not reflect those of DNA)